Science journalism and science in India
I am a huge fan of Columbo, the legendary American detective series from the 70s. It's the only show I'll make a point of recording to watch. Why? Like so many people, I can't resist a good mystery. But more than that, I love to see Columbo ask all his seemingly-irrelevant little questions, slowly piece together the evidence and somehow pull it all together with a brilliant observation that catches out the bad guy or gall just when they think they've got away with murder.
That's how we journalists often work -- taking tiny pieces of material from here and there, to build up a story, all in the hope of revealing a bigger truth.
As a journalist, my favourite story came in 2007, when I started to investigate a global network of bogus universities, scamming poor students by selling them worthless degrees. When the piece finally aired on the BBC last year, it was the first time I felt I'd made a difference to someone's life - a real Columbo moment. But the truth is that, on a day-to-day level, a reporter's life is more often about simply communicating the news.
I wrote my first published science article - an interview with the neuroscientist Susan Greenfield - for a student newspaper while I was at Oxford reading engineering. After graduating, I eventually landed a traineeship with ITN, learning to be a television news producer. To my surprise, my engineering training came in useful. I picked up the technical side of the business quickly. After that, I joined the BBC as a local news reporter, and last year went freelance to devote my time solely to reporting on science and engineering.
It's been a rollercoaster, taking me all over the world, reporting topics like mathematical symbols and hardware hackers. Right now, I'm New Delhi while I research my first book, about science in India. The country is a hotbed of scientific activity - space missions, biotechnology, big pharma research - making it a goldmine of stories for any reporter.
Beautiful as it is, though, living in India is not easy. In Delhi particularly, the rates of attacks and sexual harassment against women are so high that it's rare to see a woman out by herself in the evenings. Being a female scientist in India is even tougher, as I learned while surfing the forums at Nature Network - a global social site for people working in science, run by the journal, Nature. According to the posts, women scientists routinely suffer sexism, sometimes outright abuse, at the hands of male colleagues.
The paradox is that this is one of few nations in the world with a female President, and just this weekend I watched a platoon of female soldiers at a military parade -- all proving that this isn't so much an institutional problem as one of attitudes and prejudices. Women do have access to the careers that they want, they just can't be guaranteed an easy time in the job. Like all abuse, though, nothing can be done about it until women speak out. Even on the Nature Network forums, the posts have been anonymous and nobody has felt comfortable naming names.
The sad fact is that female scientists feel too intimidated or afraid to make their negative experiences public. So for now, this is one important story that remains untold.
Angela Saini is an award-winning science journalist based in London, who is currently living in New Delhi. Her first book, Geek Nation, will be published by Hodder & Stoughton in 2011. Her website is: http://www.angelasaini.co.uk/
Comments
Ruth Wilson (UKRC moderator):
Hi Angela Thanks very much for being our guest blogger all the way from India. I shall look forward to your book. What\'s the focus - history? Current developments? Will you look at women at all? Are there any women in positions of power with regard to science, engineering and technology in India? Best wishes, Ruth
Malcolm Davies:
Hi Angela - (my favourite TV programme is the Sopranos and my best news story was the take-over of Manchester City making it the richest (AND BEST) football club in the world!!!!!!!). What are the views amonst Indian scientists and the general public about \'climate change\' and particularly the Copenhagen talks - seemingly struggling at the minute. Are there any high profile women scientists or politicians at the forefront of the debate? I understand that the England women\'s cricket team is touring India and playing a number of test matches next year - are you interested and will you be watching? Do you think that it\'s ever possible to change attitudes? All the best Malc ps great blog by the way.
Angela Saini:
Hi Ruth: My book is about the scientists and scientific institutions that are helping to turn India into a science superpower - It\'s a broad subject but so far my research has been fascinating! There is a real passion for science and engineering in this country, so I\'m also trying to find where the roots of that passion lie and the weird and wonderful work that cutting-edge researchers are doing. Although, like I mentioned in my blog post, being a female scientist isn\'t always easy in India, there are in fact some women doing great things in science. The head of the country\'s largest biotech firm, Kiran Muzumdar Shaw, has been described as the \"biotech queen\""
Rachel:
Hi Angela, You have tmade some interesting observations about the culture facing female scientists in India. Do you know whether it is similar for female journalists? It\'s odd that women reach such senior and influential positions in India, but still have to tolerate such abuse. You imply that there is a noticeable difference between India and the UK in this. Do you think that this is partly because we are so \'politically correct\' in the UK that we just will not accept this kind of language or behaviour any more? I have often heard people over here criticising the UK for being TOO politically correct - but I am inclined to think that zero tolerance of rudeness and abuse is A Good Thing. It is sad if people with good intentions are sometimes vilified for accidentally causing offence, but on the whole political correctness has cleaned up our act in the UK and made the lives of women a lot easier. What do you think?
Nishant:
Hey Angela, Nice blog. Delhi is probably not the best place to be in India, if you are a women. However, the conditions have improved a lot in the last decade (improved journalism has been an important reason). Anyways, as you write your book, I believe understanding the cultural context would be a major challenge. How are you planning to go about it? Also what are the broad themes you would look at before you solve the puzzle?! :) Cheers Nishant www.nishantranka.blogspot.com
Ruth Wilson (UKRC moderator):
Hi Angela, I looked up the two women you mentioned – here are the links in case anyone is interested: Kiran Mazumdar-Sha: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kiran_Mazumdar-Shaw Professor Godbole: http://cts.iisc.ernet.in/Personnel/rohini.html If you go to her personal pages, you find out she prefers showing a picture of the Mona Lisa to showing one of herself ☺
Angela:
Hi Rachel: Thanks for your comments! I think political correctness is a strange, catch-all term for anything that comes in the way of causing offence. In fact, it almost equates the abuse of a woman in the workplace with, say, a throwaway, one-off comment made by someone who should know better. They may both be wrong, but one is completely intolerable while the other is commonplace and therefore impossible (perhaps even unfair) to police. My personal feeling is that we need to exercise some common sense but make sure we intervene when things get out of hand. Hi Nishant: Yes, you\'re right, Delhi is a nasty exception for women... I was in Mumbai last week and it was wonderful there, and not at all unsafe. But yes, things have improved since I was last here six years ago. The cultural context is actually the major focus of my book. My goal is to find out why science is popular in India, and the ways in which it is practised -- There is a completely different set of issues from most of the rest of the world... things like religion, caste, poverty, hierarchy and of course India\'s vast scale. If you would like to know when the book\'s released then please do send an email to geek@angelasaini.co.uk.
Shilpa Jain:
Hi Angela, I should commend you on writing-researching on women scientists in India. I am curious to know whether you plan to interview women scientists in Universities across India. It would be interesting to know about differences in the number, attitude and motivational levels in women in different state Universities. I also wonder whether there any organizations that nurture women scientists in India. Good Luck. Shilpa
Angela Saini:
Hi Shilpa: Thanks for your kind comments. I am actually this week at the Indian Science Congress in Trivandrum, Kerala, and I\'ve been pleasantly surprised by the number of female scientists (especially young women) attending. On Sunday the Prime Minister, Manmohan Singh, highlighted the need to support more female scientists -- so I\'m sure there will be lots more opportunities for women in the future. As for my book, it\'s not my plan to interview female scientists specifically, but if I get the opportunity then I will! Happy New Year, and thanks to everyone who read this blog post at the end of 2009! Angela
Ruth Wilson (UKRC moderator):
Happy new year to you too Angela, and all the blog visitors. Its been great having you join us from India - I\'m looking forward to reading the book.
biotech training india:
I was very pleased to find this site.
I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.


